A la carte Side Dishes. Chicken & Beef Dishes Come With A Tray Of White Rice. Our Trays are 10 inch x 12 inch deep trays, serving approx. 10 people. Let us help you determine the size you need. Chafing Racks Available To Purchase.
(1/2 Tray, $15.00)
in artichoke plum tomato sauce
(1/2 Tray, $15.00)
Lean beef, peppers, onions, sesame seeds in Jay's traditional brown sauce
In Jay's own marinara sauce
Chicken, Eggplant & Fresh Mozzarella in creamy pink sauce
Beef, Chicken or Turkey
Serves 10. ($4.50 each) Boars Head Turkey wrapped around our famous stuffing, topped with turkey gravy.
Huge meaty wings. Not your average party wings!
Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers with balsamic glaze
Meatballs, tomato sauce & mozzarella on our own garlic knots! MMMMM!
With Ranch Dip
With Our Special Pina Colada Dip. Used as an appetizer or dessert.
Our newest creation
We have a large assortment of Specialty Bread Puddings: apple, blueberry, cherry and many more.
We bake our pastries, cookies, custom-designed party cakes, photo cakes, cupcake cakes.
Made to order, any size, flavor or design. Prices on request.
With dressing on the side.
(Add Grilled Chicken To Any Salad $6.99 per lb.)
Chicken, craisins, almonds, Romaine, parmesan cheese, raspberry vinaigrette
With mushrooms, bacon bits, carrots, eggs & onions
(Add grilled chicken for $6.99 lb.)
Romaine, Granny Smith apples, walnuts, dried cherries, crumbled feta cheese, balsamic glaze
Spinach, sundried tomatoes, orzo pasta, olives, lemon vinaigrette and grilled chicken
Special Request? If you have a favorite item or special request, please ask us. We will be happy to oblige!
Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, American & Swiss. 10 servings.
Includes Rolls 6.00/person
Beautifully decorated platters of meats, cheeses & basic salads. with choice of our own fresh kaiser, dinner, club rolls or other specialty breads and pickles, olives, mustard & mayonnaise.
Serves approx. 12-15 People. 8 full size wraps cut into 24 pieces.
Ham, salami, pepperoni & provolone with lettuce and tomatoes on a loaf of Jay's fresh Italian bread
10 assorted sandwiches on fresh rolls cut into squares. Serves approx. 10
We Bake Our Pastries, Cookies, Custom Designed Party Cakes, Photo Cakes, Cupcake Cakes. Made to order, any size, flavor or design. Prices on request.
Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato
Ham, turkey, American cheese, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato
With balsamic vinegrette
Chicken cutlet, bacon, cheddar and BBQ sauce
Grilled Chicken always available in place of chicken cutlet. Heroes serve 4-6 people per foot. Heroes come wrapped in boxes, not on boards. We do not cut them. $2 charge per foot to cut specialty heroes and platter them.
Jay's Deli is located directly on Route 32, sandwiched between Rutledge Avenue and Tracie Lane in Highland Mills, New York. Our building is nested in the hamlet of Highland Mills, part of the Village of Woodbury, 2 miles north of the Woodbury Common Premium Outlets. Being in the heart of the village conveniently places us across from the Woodbury Pharmacy and a stone's throw away from the Post Office. Jay's Deli is a proud member of the Woodbury Chamber of Commerce, serving hundreds of satisfied customers daily.
Give us a call anytime:
Our address is:
534 State Route 32
Highland Mills, NY 10930
Our normal operating hours are:
Monday - Saturday 7 AM - 8 PM
Sunday 7 AM - 5PM
Catering orders are prepared daily for all meals and can be delivered.